Saturday, 21 November 2026

A long technical note on aspects of ecclesiology in relation to the Eucharist: the case of the 24 ‘sui generis’


 

In referring to various denominations and churches within the broad Christian family (that is all persons baptised into Christ) we sometimes encounter difficulties in terminology. This is natural in a contested world.  For example, ‘Northern Ireland’ may be referred to as ‘The North’, ‘The North of Ireland’, ‘The Six Counties’ and ’Ulster’  depending on your view of what it is and what it should be. Likewise, terms such as ‘Catholic’, ‘Catholic Church’, ‘Roman Catholic Church’, ’Eastern Orthodox’ may invite disagreements.  Some question whether some Christian churches are really churches at all but ‘ecclesial communities’ (though the word ‘ecclesial’ means church).

In an attempt to clear a little bit of fog I attempt, in this blog and two others next week, to outline my understanding of how Christianity divided out over the centuries into separate churches and how these regard each other especially in the context of this Eucharist blog series, Bread for the Journey.

When the Christian faith spread out from Jerusalem in all directions to the East, the West, the North and the South in the late 1st Century and early 2nd Century, there was not yet a fixed New Testament canon, nor the later ecumenical creeds, nor a universally standardised system of governance. Nevertheless, local churches were already led by bishops, presbyters and deacons, and shared a common apostolic faith expressed in preaching, sacramental life and worship.   We know from many sources including the writings of Polycarp, Ignatius of Antioch, the Didache and others that a primitive form of Eucharistic liturgy was used across the scattered Christian communities.

Rome assumed importance over time not least because, by tradition, Saints Paul and Peter were martyred there.  Given the political role of Rome across much of Southern and Central Europe, North Africa and the Middle East, it is not surprising that the emerging Christian church looked to Rome for spiritual guidance and support. The conversion of Emperor Constantine in 312 A.D. was a turning point. This signalled the arrival of Christendom which would remain a political as well as spiritual force for well over a millennium.

Two major divisions occurred over the following centuries: the Great Schism of 1054 and the Protestant Reformation of the 16th Century. However, there were schisms and partings of the way long before 1054 when a few churches went their own way for reasons to be touched on later.

Today, there are 24 Churches which are all in full communion with the Pope, Bishop of Rome.  They are referred to as sui iuris (self-governing churches). They are under the jurisdiction of the Roman pontiff but retain their own distinctive liturgical rites and self-governance.  Some might suggest that they provide a clue as to how Christians could move towards greater unity in the coming period.  These churches are as follows:

The Latin or Roman Catholic Church (to which I belong)

23 Eastern Catholic Churches that are in full communion with Rome:

Alexandrian Tradition

Coptic Catholic Church

Ethiopian Catholic Church

Eritrean Catholic Church

Antiochene (West Syriac) Tradition

Maronite Church

Syriac Catholic Church

Syro-Malankara Catholic Church

Armenian Tradition

Armenian Catholic Church (not to be confused with the Armenian Apostolic Church)

East Syriac (Chaldean) Tradition

Chaldean Catholic Church

Syro-Malabar Catholic Church

Byzantine Tradition (these have preserved the Byzantine Rite, spirituality and liturgical traditions of the Christian East)

Albanian Greek Catholic Church

Belarusian Greek Catholic Church

Bulgarian Greek Catholic Church

Croatian and Serbian Byzantine Catholic Church

Greek Byzantine Catholic Church

Hungarian Greek Catholic Church

Italo-Albanian Catholic Church

Macedonian Greek Catholic Church

Melkite Greek Catholic Church

Romanian Greek Catholic Church

Russian Greek Catholic Church

Ruthenian Greek Catholic Church

Slovak Greek Catholic Church

Ukrainian Greek Catholic Church

To simplify matters, the 24 'sui generis' Churches are subject to the authority of the Pope as successor to Saint Peter; they are said to be in full communion with the See of Peter located in Rome. 

The next time a stranger might ask you if you are 'religious' or 'spiritual' you could reply by declaring that you are a 'sui generis' Catholic!  You would be literally saying that you are 'of its own kind' or 'unique'.  As such, one is in full communion with the Pope in as much as one can be but self-governing when it comes to our own individual adaptation and application of the shared faith of 1.4 billion Catholics! In that regard, you would not be unusual.

Next Tuesday, I will pick up on this long technical note to look at Churches that separated from Rome prior to the great schism of 1054.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Note: only a member of this blog may post a comment.