Thursday, 19 November 2026

Before scholasticism

 

The question of a proper name: The Ancient Liturgy of Spain

The first millennium was marked by the lived experience of the Catholic Church, united in faith, sacramental life and apostolic ministry. The Church confessed the faith expressed in the Nicene-Constantinopolitan Creed and recognised the special primacy of the Bishop of Rome as successor of St Peter, though the precise scope and exercise of that primacy would become a subject of increasing theological and ecclesiological debate between East and West.

At a later stage, greater doctrinal and theological precision concerning the Eucharist emerged, particularly through the teaching of ecumenical councils such as the Fourth Lateran Council (1215), which employed the term transubstantiation, and in the theological synthesis of St Thomas Aquinas.

The witness and teachings of St Isidore of Seville (c. 560-636) show that belief in Christ's Eucharistic presence, the sacrificial nature of the Mass and the unity of the Church around the altar were already firmly established centuries before the scholastic era.
In his work, DeEcclesiasticis Officiis (On Ecclesiastical Offices), we have one of the most important descriptions of the Eucharistic liturgy in seventh-century Spain. In the modern English translation by Thomas L. Knoebel (trans.), Isidore of Seville: De Ecclesiasticis Officiis (Paulist Press, 2008) a number of key references to the Eucharist emerge.  In Book 1, chapter 11, St Isidore discusses the important symbolism of the altar, the sacrifice and Christ.  In chapter 15 - On the Sacrifices, St Isidore explains Christian sacrifice in relation to Old Testament sacrifices.  Christ's sacrifice fulfils and supersedes the ancient sacrifices.  In chapter 18 of the same book, St Isidore considers how the consecrated bread and wine retain visible appearances while conveying the reality of Christ’s presence. Chapters 19 explains the liturgical prayers following communion.

In chapter 18 St Isidore writes:
For the bread that we break is the body of Christ (1 Cor. 10), who said: ‘I am the living bread who came down from heaven’ (John 6). The wine is his blood, and this is what is written: I am the true vine (John vi). But bread is called the body of Christ because it strengthens the body, while wine is referred to the blood of Christ because it produces blood in the flesh.  While these things are visible, they are nevertheless sanctified by the Holy Spirit and pass into the sacrament of the divine body.
He provides significant evidence for what the Catholic Church already believed and practised centuries before the scholastic period:
We believe that the sacrifice for the faithful departed should be offered for their repose, and that praying for them is a pious duty, since the Church holds that it was handed down by the apostles themselves. Throughout the world the Catholic Church holds this, so that, if she did not believe that sins are forgiven the faithful departed, she would not offer alms for their spirits, nor offer the sacrifice to God.
The original, in Latin, reads as follows:
Sacrificium pro defunctorum fidelium requie offerre, vel pro eis orare, quia per totum mundum hoc orbem custoditur, credimus quod ab ipsis apostolis traditum sit. Hoc enim ubique catholica tenet Ecclesia, quae nisi crederet fidelibus defunctis dimitti peccata, non pro eorum spiritibus vel eleemosynam faceret, vel sacrificium Deo offerret.
St Isidore, writing in the 7th Century makes two very important points regarding the teaching of the united, apostolic and universal Church:
  1. ‘the Church holds that it was handed down by the apostles themselves’.
  2. ‘Throughout the world the Catholic Church holds this’
He provides significant evidence for what the Catholic Church already believed and practised centuries before the scholastic period of the 11th-14th Centuries.

The memorial of St Isidore is held on 4 April.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Note: only a member of this blog may post a comment.