Saturday, 21 November 2026

A long technical note on aspects of ecclesiology in relation to the Eucharist: the case of the 24 ‘sui generis’


 

In referring to various denominations and churches within the broad Christian family (that is all persons baptised into Christ) we sometimes encounter difficulties in terminology. This is natural in a contested world.  For example, ‘Northern Ireland’ may be referred to as ‘The North’, ‘The North of Ireland’, ‘The Six Counties’ and ’Ulster’  depending on your view of what it is and what it should be. Likewise, terms such as ‘Catholic’, ‘Catholic Church’, ‘Roman Catholic Church’, ’Eastern Orthodox’ may invite disagreements.  Some question whether some Christian churches are really churches at all but ‘ecclesial communities’ (though the word ‘ecclesial’ means church).

In an attempt to clear a little bit of fog I attempt, in this blog and two others next week, to outline my understanding of how Christianity divided out over the centuries into separate churches and how these regard each other especially in the context of this Eucharist blog series, Bread for the Journey.

Friday, 20 November 2026

Speaking with God from the depths of the Heart

 

Sevanavank monastery beside Lake Sevan in Armenia

St Gregory of Narek (c. 950-1003) was an Armenian monk, priest, mystic, theologian and poet who lived at the Monastery of Narek in historic Armenia (now eastern Turkey). He is regarded as one of the greatest figures in Armenian Christianity and literature. His writings express a deep Christ-centred and sacramental spirituality that is part of the common Christian heritage of the first millennium whether in Rome, Constantinople, Jerusalem, Antioch or Alexandria.

What makes him particularly significant is that Pope Francis declared him a Doctor of the Church in 2015, on the 100th anniversary of the Armenian genocide in the Ottoman Empire, making him the first Armenian saint to receive that title as well as the first recognised Doctor of the Church who, during his earthly life, belonged to a Church that was not in full communion with the See of Rome.

Thursday, 19 November 2026

Before scholasticism

 

The question of a proper name: The Ancient Liturgy of Spain

The first millennium was marked by the lived experience of the Catholic Church, united in faith, sacramental life and apostolic ministry. The Church confessed the faith expressed in the Nicene-Constantinopolitan Creed and recognised the special primacy of the Bishop of Rome as successor of St Peter, though the precise scope and exercise of that primacy would become a subject of increasing theological and ecclesiological debate between East and West.

At a later stage, greater doctrinal and theological precision concerning the Eucharist emerged, particularly through the teaching of ecumenical councils such as the Fourth Lateran Council (1215), which employed the term transubstantiation, and in the theological synthesis of St Thomas Aquinas.

Wednesday, 18 November 2026

The spiritual externalities of the Mass

 


In political economy we sometimes refer to externalities. This term refers to the spill over effects (for better or worse) of behaviour of one person on others. This could apply at the level of an individual or a firm.  We can say that increased education or skills acquired by one worker enhances not only that worker’s productivity but the productivity of the company as a whole.  Another example is when the activity of a business might have a negative impact on the local environment incurring costs on other economic entities and households.

Tuesday, 17 November 2026

The Eucharistic King desires your inner beauty

 


St John of Ávila (1500-1569) was a Spanish priest, preacher, spiritual director and reformer who became one of the leading figures of Catholic renewal in sixteenth-century Spain. St John preached reform not through controversy but through conversion of heart. He was declared a Doctor of the Church relatively recently - by Pope Benedict XVI in 2012 because of the enduring value of his teaching and writings. 

When his parents died, he sold his inheritance and donated the proceeds to the poor before following the path to the priesthood. In 1531 he was imprisoned by the Inquisition on suspicion of heterodox teaching. After a lengthy investigation he was fully acquitted. During his imprisonment he deepened his meditation on Christ's Passion, a focus that would shape his preaching and spirituality for the rest of his life. His devotion to the Cross and the Eucharist became hallmarks of his ministry.  Often called the ‘Apostle of Andalusia’, he spent much of his life preaching throughout southern Spain, drawing huge crowds through the depth of his biblical teaching and personal holiness.

Monday, 16 November 2026

Made by and for love: Eucharistic insights of St Catherine of Siena

 

Picture: WallsnArt, Figurative Modern Framed Art 
Work Canvas Gallery Wrap, Lamentation [Amazon]

St Catherine of Siena (1347-1380) was a remarkable saint of her time: a mystic, a spiritual writer, a peacemaker and a woman whose influence contributed significantly to the reform of the Church at a time of some corruption and marked division. Although she lived only 33 years, her influence extended from ordinary people to Popes and rulers.  She remained a lay person of the Dominican Third Order while centring her life on Christ.

Born in 1347 as the second youngest of 25 children, Caterina Benincasa was an extraordinary woman that God blessed with profound spiritual experiences. It is believed that Christ, Mary, angels and saints appeared to her from the time she was six.  The Pope was influenced by her requests and returned home to Rome from Avignon.

In her great work, The Dialogue, which is said to have been dictated to others by the Saint in ecstasy, she writes:

Sunday, 15 November 2026

Faith and science

Today is the feast day of St Albert Magnus (c. 1200-1280) - a Dominican friar, theologian, philosopher, scientist, bishop and teacher of St. Thomas Aquinas. He is also regarded as a patron saint of the natural sciences and was declared a Doctor of the Church in 1931. 

Believing that all truth ultimately comes from God, he devoted himself to studying philosophy, theology, plants, animals, minerals, astronomy and many other fields, seeking to understand creation as a path to understanding the Creator.  Like the other great medieval theologians, he understood creation as participating in God's wisdom and saw the Eucharist as the summit of Christ's self-gift. For Albert, the study of nature and the worship of God belonged together because both ultimately lead to the same divine source.

In an age that often sets science and faith against one another, St Albert Magnus reminds us that the careful study of creation and the reverent worship of the Creator are not rivals but companions. The same God whose wisdom is revealed in the natural world gives himself to us most profoundly in the Eucharist.

Saturday, 14 November 2026

The same Christ: from Holy Communion to contemplative prayer

Many decades ago, as a novice in a Cistercian monastery, I was instructed in the ways of contemplative prayer with particular reference to the Cloud of Unknowing.  I must admit that it was not quite my attraction and I did not persevere in the way which entailed two blocks of 30 minutes each every day using the ‘Jesus prayer’ (Lord Jesus, Son of the Living God be merciful to me a poor sinner).  I either fell asleep or my mind wandered far and wide! Yet, I believe that the experience was a valuable one if only to demonstrate that the way to God is not primarily through our efforts but through allowing ourselves to be vulnerable, distracted, unsure as well as open to divine grace in the dance hall that is one’s mind.  I realised – to some extent - that the same Christ that I received daily in Holy Communion is the same Christ that meets me in contemplative prayer and whose glory is revealed on Mount Tabor.

Friday, 13 November 2026

Use it or lose it

 


Sunday 15 November 2026

Lectio Divina:*

Proverbs 21:10-31

Psalm 128 (127)

1 Thessalonians 5:1-6

Matthew 25:14-30

(See also Mark 13:33-37 and Luke 19:11-27)

 

Meditatio:

‘to all those who have, more will be given, and they will have an abundance.’ (Matthew 25:29a)

Commentary:

When I consider how my light is spent

Ere half my days in this dark world and wide,

And that one talent which is death to hide

Lodg'd with me useless

(John Milton, 1608-1674)

 Milton's words bring us directly to today's Gospel. The parable of the talents is not primarily about money. It is about life itself. It is about what God has entrusted to each one of us and what we do with it.

Mystery of mysteries


St. Nektarios of Aegina (1846-1920) was remembered in the Orthodox churches of the East earlier this week (9 November). Originally from what is now modern-day Turkey, he served as a monk and priest in various locations including Cairo where he served as a bishop for one year. Though very popular with the people, some of his clerical colleagues plotted against him using false accusations. He was suspended from his post without explanation or a fair hearing. Rather than defend himself aggressively, he accepted humiliation with patience, a trait that became one of the hallmarks of his holiness [source]. 

Thursday, 12 November 2026

Faith before mystery


St. Tikhon of Zadonsk (1724-1783) was a Russian Orthodox monk, bishop, spiritual writer, and saint  who is venerated as a saint throughout the Orthodox Churches and whose primary commemoration is on 13 August.  He believed that Christianity is fundamentally a living relationship with the risen Christ. This conviction gave Holy Communion a central place in his spirituality. It is here, in the Eucharist, that we meet the risen Christ Himself and receive divine life.

In his teaching, he emphasised repentance and confession, including reconciliation with those with whom one is in conflict, before receiving Holy Communion. He also stressed the importance of fasting and prayer as part of one's preparation for the sacrament.  We should approach this sacrament with reverence and attentiveness, never as a merely habitual or routine practice.  Tikhon regarded the Eucharist as heavenly nourishment for the soul, strengthening believers in their struggle against sin and helping them grow in union with Christ.

Wednesday, 11 November 2026

The Eucharistic destination of creation


An important witness to Eucharistic spirituality in the East during the first millennium was St Maximus the Confessor (c. 580 – 662 A.D).  His theology of participation (theosis), cosmic liturgy and union with Christ provides strong foundations for Eucharistic theology. 

Maximus developed and Christianised the ancient theme of 'exit and return', teaching that humanity was created in the image of God and that salvation restores and perfects humanity's communion with God in Christ.   This emphasis on divinisation or theosis helped secure Maximus' place in Eastern Christian theology, as these concepts have always held an important place in the East.

His principal feast is celebrated on 21 January in the Eastern Orthodox Church, while the Catholic Church commemorates him on 13 August.

For Maximus, the Eucharist is not merely a sacrament among others but a real participation in humanity's union with God and an anticipation of the final reconciliation of all creation in Christ.  The modern Greek Orthodox theologian, philosopher and priest Fr Loudovikos argues that Maximus offers an alternative to both individualism, where the self is self-sufficient and; collectivism, where persons disappear into the whole.  Theosis or divinisation does not entail absorption into God but, rather, personal communion, loving reciprocity fulfilled relationality.

He maintains that for Maximus, being itself is fundamentally Eucharistic, meaning that existence reaches its fulfilment not in self-possession but in communion, gift, reciprocity and loving participation in God and others.  This approach sees creation as unfinished and movement as something positive and essential; history is the journey toward full communion with God.

To borrow a contemporary cliché, it is possible to claim that with Christ we are, indeed, on ‘the right side of history’.

Tuesday, 10 November 2026

Becoming what we receive


Pope St. Leo I (c. 400-461) is one of the most important early witnesses to Catholic Eucharistic belief. His writings emphasise both the Real Presence of Christ in the Eucharist and the transformative effect of receiving Holy Communion.  One of his most famous statements is:

Monday, 9 November 2026

From the Passover Lamb to the Eucharist

pic: Durham Cathedral

Earlier this year, in a series of posts published under the blog label Jewish roots, I explore the Jewish roots of the Christian Eucharist.  I drew on the work of Brant Pitre among others when I wrote this:

One of the clearest places where the Jewish imprint on Christianity remains visible is in the Holy Mass, the Eucharist. Catholics believe that this sacrament was instituted at the Last Supper and marks the new covenant—the new Passover—in the blood of Jesus Christ, shed for all peoples outside the gates of Jerusalem. According to the Synoptic Gospels (Matthew, Mark, and Luke), the Last Supper was a ritual Jewish meal, structured as a Passover celebration like those observed by thousands of Jewish families at the time.

Long before modern scholars began to emphasise the Jewish roots of the Eucharist, they were already apparent in the writings of the Anglo-Saxon theologian, Doctor and saint, Bede the Venerable (c. 673-735).  Bede understood the Eucharist as the fulfilment of Old Testament figures such as the manna and Passover lamb.  In his commentaries on the Temple, the Tabernacle and the Passover, for example, he saw the Eucharist as the completion of God's saving plan rather than as an isolated ritual. The history of Israel culminates in Christ, and Christ continues to nourish his Church sacramentally.

Sunday, 8 November 2026

Recent stories of Irish women and the Eucharist

Born in 1907 in Kanturk in North Cork, Edel Mary Quinn was one of Ireland's great twentieth-century lay apostles as well as an outstanding member of the Legion of Mary which she joined in 1929.  She went as an envoy to East Africa in 1936 and died at the age of 36 in 1944. Her cause for canonisation remains active. In 1994 she was declared Venerable by Pope John Paul II, recognising the heroic virtue of her life.  Although reports of favours and healings have been attributed to her intercession, no miracle has yet been officially approved for her beatification.  Many who have studied her life have remarked that her perseverance despite illness seems extraordinary, leading some to describe her life itself as a kind of miracle.

According to one source, her given name at baptism was Edelweiss (the name of a tough but beautiful white alpine flower which was shortened to Edel).  This account, however, is not confirmed by other sources as far as I can tell.  I did find her birth certificate through a public online search and it turned up as Edelle at birth.  I do like the image and some literary license seems justified in this case.



Her family moved from town to town as her father worked for a bank. It is believed that a French man named Pierre Landrin who was manager of a tile company in Dublin where Edel worked proposed marriage to her. God had other plans for Edel. She had hoped to become a nun. Yet illness redirected her vocation and ultimately prepared her for the mission that would make her known throughout East Africa.  Following a diagnosis of tuberculosis in 1932 Edel spent 18 months in a sanatorium in County Wicklow.

Saturday, 7 November 2026

Reign of the Eucharist in all hearts


Servant of God Frank Duff (1889–1980) founded the Legion of Mary in 1921.  The ‘Legion’ was present in practically every parish in Ireland in the course of the 20th Century. While I was approached more than once in the  1980s I never joined up – I was involved in another lay Catholic movement.  Yet, I retain a great respect and admiration for the work of the Legion – quiet, persistent, not ostentatious and ever faithful to Catholic tradition and present-day authority.

Frank Duff died on this day in 1980.

The Legion spread from Ireland to every corner of the globe. Its purpose and mission was to mobilise ordinary lay Catholics in works of prayer and apostolic outreach to spread love for God, Mary, the Church and the Sacraments. Where the Society of St Vincent de Paul brought material relief to the poor in each parish, the Legion of Mary brought spiritual help and encouragement.

The founder placed  great emphasis on frequent – even daily – participation in the Mass along with eucharistic spirituality. In the handbook of the Legion, Frank Duff wrote:

The Eucharist is the centre and source of grace: therefore it must be the very keystone of the Legion scheme. The most intense activity will accomplish nothing of value if it forgets for a moment that the main object is to establish the reign of the Eucharist in all hearts. For therefore is fulfilled the purpose for which Jesus came into the world. That purpose was to communicate himself to souls so that he might make them one with him. The means of that communication is chiefly in the Holy Eucharist. The Eucharist is the infinite good. For in that Sacrament is Jesus Himself.

Friday, 6 November 2026

The great cloud of Irish witnesses


Today we honour all the Irish saints including the many who are known to God alone in The Feast of All Saints of Ireland (Féile Naomh uile na hÉireann).  On my daily walks in the surrounding countryside I sometimes think of the people who lived and worked on this land down the centuries. From the early monks to the Cistercians who established Duiske Abbey in Graignamanagh in 1204 to those who toiled on the land and in the homestead and provided for others.  Many faced hardships, oppression and persecution that we can hardly imagine. For them, the Mass was central and some risked and gave their lives for it.

Ireland has a proud tradition of saints and monastic founders. Almost every parish has a local saint and an associated holy well or church ruin.  It is hard to believe that there is more than one local Irish saint for every day of the year.  Ranging from the early missionary period associated with Saint Patrick and those who came after him – notably Brigid and Colmcille amongst a host of others – to the martyrs and holy persons of later centuries we have a high density of sainthood per square kilometre!

Thursday, 5 November 2026

Lamps lit and hearts awake


Sunday 8 November 2026

Lectio Divina:

Wisdom 6:12-16

Psalm 63 (62)

1 Thessalonians 4:13-18

Matthew 25:1-13


Meditatio:

‘Keep awake therefore, for you know neither the day nor the hour.’ (Matthew 25:13)

Commentary:

Life itself is not complicated. More often than not, we are the ones who complicate it.

Among the many insights offered by the world's spiritual traditions are two simple but profound practices: mindfulness and faithful living. While these terms are often associated with Buddhism, they also lie close to the heart of the Jewish and Christian tradition. Scripture repeatedly calls us to attentiveness before God and loving action towards others.

The Book of Wisdom speaks of wisdom as something living and active, waiting to be discovered by those who seek it with an open heart. "She hastens to make herself known to those who desire her" (Wisdom 6:13). God is not distant or hidden. The challenge is not God's absence but our inattentiveness. We become distracted by the noise around us and lose touch with the presence already at work within us.

Wednesday, 4 November 2026

Seeing Cana through Eucharistic eyes


In common with many first-millennium Christian writers, St Peter Chrysologus (c. 380-450), Archbishop of Ravenna and Doctor of the Church, did not leave a systematic treatise on the Eucharist in the way later theologians would. Nevertheless, his sermons contain significant Eucharistic teaching. He belongs to the great patristic era often described as the ‘Golden Age of the Fathers’ (fourth and fifth centuries). Like his contemporary St Leo the Great, Chrysologus understood the Eucharist as a true sacramental participation in Christ's Body and Blood.

One of his most striking Eucharistic passages comes from a sermon reflecting on the Epiphany, the Baptism of the Lord, and the wedding feast at Cana:

Tuesday, 3 November 2026

More than a symbol

St. Hilary of Poitiers (c. 310-367), best known as a defender of the divinity of Christ against Arianism, also left an important witness to the Eucharist. He belongs to the generation of Nicene Fathers who defended the orthodox faith in the decades following the first Council of Nicaea (325 A.D.).  St Hilary’s most famous Eucharistic text appears in De Trinitate (On the Trinity), Book VIII. One of his strongest statements reads:

For if in truth the Word has been made flesh and we in very truth receive the Word made flesh as food from the Lord, are we not bound to believe that He abides in us naturally, Who, born as a man, has assumed the nature of our flesh now inseparable from Himself, and has conjoined the nature of His own flesh to the nature of the eternal Godhead in the sacrament by which His flesh is communicated to us?  (De Trinitate, VIII, 13).  

Monday, 2 November 2026

Praying for the faithful departed at Mass

 

Today, across the Roman Catholic Church, the memorial of ‘All Souls’ – or Commemoration of All the Faithful Departed - is commemorated.  

Early roots
Although some have suggested that Christians built on earlier, pagan, rites of prayer for the dead, the practice of prayers and special masses for the dead developed independently of those practices and should not be confused with them.

Although the theology and liturgical shape of the day have developed over the centuries, there is evidence of prayer for the dead and of offering the Eucharistic sacrifice for them, from the fourth century, if not earlier. Their inclusion within the Eucharistic liturgy itself probably dates to the fourth century. In a work attributed to St Cyril of Jerusalem (Mystagogical Catechesis 5.9), we read:

Sunday, 1 November 2026

The saints and the Eucharist

Something that strikes me again and again is the witness of the Saints from the earliest times. Their lives were what might be termed ‘eucharistic’; they lived the mystery of Christ’s death and resurrection.  They managed, by grace, to turn their lives around and remain anchored in Christ.  In recent centuries, there are hundreds of officially canonised saints and unknown numbers of others who found their daily or weekly sustenance in the Eucharist.  Their approach and thinking was informed by scripture and tradition.  They accepted in trust what was given and received about the Eucharist.  For some, the Eucharist was a particularly emphasised practice or focus of devotion as we see with the many ‘Apostles of the Eucharist’ such as St Peter Julian Eymard, founder the Blessed Sacrament congregation.